Abhinna (Abhiññā): Six Supernormal Knowledges

Below is an overview of the Abhinnas as described in Buddhist texts and other resources. Abhinnas consists of six supernatural powers said to be exhibited by some meditators after attaining Fourth Jhana.

The Abhinnas: Supernormal Knowledges in Early Buddhist Texts, Personal Testimonies, and Traditional Narratives

I. Unveiling the Abhinnas: Definitions and Canonical Context

The concept of Abhiññā, or supernormal knowledges, holds a significant, albeit sometimes controversial, place within Buddhist meditative traditions. These extraordinary capacities, said to arise from profound mental cultivation, are detailed in early Buddhist texts, particularly the Pali Canon and its authoritative commentary, the Visuddhimagga. Understanding the Abhinnas requires an exploration of their definition, classification, and the crucial distinction between mundane psychic powers and the ultimate supramundane knowledge of liberation.

A. Defining “Abhinna”: Etymological Roots and Conceptual Scope in Early Buddhism

The Pali term abhiññā is generally translated as “higher knowledge,” “direct knowledge,” or “supernormal knowledge”.¹ Etymologically, it derives from the prefix abhi, signifying “higher,” “special,” or “complete,” combined with the root ñā, meaning “to know”.¹ This etymology underscores that these states are not merely magical feats but profound modes of understanding and perception that transcend ordinary human capabilities.

In the early Buddhist scriptures, abhiññā appears in varied contexts. Sometimes, it refers to a broader category of special knowledge that is conducive to the attainment of Nibbāna (Nirvana). For instance, certain core practices of the Buddhist path, such as the Noble Eightfold Path itself, the Four Applications of Mindfulness (Satipaṭṭhāna), and the Four Bases of Spiritual Power (Iddhipāda), are described as conditions leading to abhiññā.¹ This suggests an initial understanding of abhiññā as deeply integrated with the overall journey towards liberation.

However, the term also came to denote a specific set of extraordinary psychic powers. The Visuddhimagga, a comprehensive meditation manual compiled by the 5th-century scholar Buddhaghosa, plays a pivotal role in systematizing the understanding of these specific Abhinnas within the Theravada tradition.³ This systematization tends to focus on an enumerated list of powers, which became the standard understanding in later commentarial literature.

This development indicates a gradual evolution in the application of the term “Abhinna.” While early Sutta references often link abhiññā to fundamental path factors essential for Nibbāna, suggesting a wide soteriological importance beyond mere psychic abilities ¹, later texts and commentaries, most notably the Visuddhimagga, predominantly emphasize a specific list of six supernormal powers.³ This points towards a progressive concretization, and perhaps a narrowing, of the term’s common usage over centuries. The Visuddhimagga, in its role as a systematizing treatise ⁴, was instrumental in this shift. Despite this evolution, the core principle of “higher knowledge” remains central. The implication is that while the powers themselves are extraordinary, their original framing may have been more intricately connected with the comprehensive path of mental purification and insight, rather than being viewed as isolated or purely magical abilities.

B. The Sixfold Classification of Abhinnas: A Detailed Exposition from the Pali Canon and Visuddhimagga

The classical Buddhist texts, including the Pali Canon and the Visuddhimagga, consistently present a standard list of six Abhinnas.⁵ These are:

1. Iddhi-vidha (Various Psychic Powers): This category encompasses a range of abilities manifesting mastery over the physical realm. Descriptions in canonical sources like the Samaññaphala Sutta (DN 2) ⁷ and the Visuddhimagga ⁸ include:
   • Being one, becoming manifold; having become manifold, becoming one again.
   • Appearing and disappearing at will.
   • Passing unimpeded through walls, ramparts, and mountains as if through air.
   • Diving into and out of the earth as if it were water.
   • Walking on water without sinking as if on dry land.
   • Sitting cross-legged and flying through the air like a winged bird.
   • Touching and stroking the sun and moon, so mighty and powerful.
   • Exercising mastery with the body even as far as the Brahma worlds.
2. Dibba-sota (Divine Ear or Clairaudience): The ability to hear sounds both human and divine, whether far or near, surpassing the range of normal auditory perception.³
3. Ceto-pariya-ñāṇa (Penetration of Others’ Minds or Telepathy): Also referred to as parassa ceto-pariya-ñāṇa, this is the capacity to directly know the minds and mental states of other beings.³ This includes discerning minds with greed, hatred, or delusion from those without, and recognizing developed or undeveloped states of mind.
4. Pubbe-nivāsānussati-ñāṇa (Remembrance of Former Existences or Retrocognition): The ability to recall one’s own manifold past lives, including details such as names, experiences, and circumstances of birth and death in those previous existences.³
5. Dibba-cakkhu (Divine Eye or Clairvoyance): Also known as yathā-kammūpaga-ñāṇa (knowledge of the passing away and reappearance of beings according to their kamma) or cutūpapāta-ñāṇa (knowledge of death and rebirth). This is the power to see beings passing away from one state of existence and being reborn in another, understanding how their actions (kamma) influence their destinies.³ One sees beings as inferior or superior, fair or ugly, fortunate or unfortunate, in accordance with their deeds.
6. Āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa (Knowledge of the Extinction of All Cankers/Taints): This is the direct knowledge and realization of the complete destruction of all mental defilements (āsavas – sensual craving, craving for existence, and ignorance), which culminates in the attainment of Arahantship, the state of a fully liberated being.⁵

This sixfold list is frequently encountered in the Sutta Pitaka, with key references found in discourses such as Digha Nikaya 34, Majjhima Nikaya 4, 6, and 77, Anguttara Nikaya III.99 and V.23, Samyutta Nikaya 15.9, and Puggalapaññatti 271 and 239.⁵ The Samaññaphala Sutta (DN 2) provides a particularly vivid and sequential description of the attainment of these powers as fruits of the contemplative life.² The Visuddhimagga dedicates Chapters XI through XIII to a detailed exposition of these Abhinnas, explaining their nature and the methods for their development.³

C. The Mundane versus the Supramundane: Understanding the Ultimate Aim

A critical distinction within the Abhinna framework is between those powers considered lokiya (mundane, worldly) and the one that is lokuttara (supramundane, transcendental).² The first five Abhinnas—iddhi-vidha, dibba-sota, ceto-pariya-ñāṇa, pubbe-nivāsānussati-ñāṇa, and dibba-cakkhu—fall into the mundane category. These are said to be attainable through the “utmost perfection in mental concentration” (samādhi).⁵

In contrast, the sixth Abhinna, āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa (the knowledge of the extinction of all cankers), is uniquely supramundane. It is attained not merely through concentration but through the development of penetrating insight (vipassanā) into the true nature of reality.⁵ This Abhinna represents the ultimate goal of the Buddhist path: the complete liberation from suffering and the cycle of rebirth (saṃsāra), and the destruction of all ignorance.²

Often, the last three Abhinnas (pubbe-nivāsānussati-ñāṇa, dibba-cakkhu, and āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa) are grouped together and referred to as te-vijjā (the threefold higher knowledge).² The Buddha himself is described as having attained these three knowledges on the night of his enlightenment, with the knowledge of the destruction of the cankers being the final and definitive realization.²

This classification into mundane and supramundane establishes a clear soteriological hierarchy. The texts consistently differentiate āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa from the other five powers.² While the initial five are achievable primarily through the cultivation of profound serenity and concentration (samatha), the sixth necessitates the arising of wisdom (vipassanā).⁵ This aligns with the broader Buddhist therapeutic model where a calm, concentrated mind provides the stable foundation upon which insight can arise to eradicate mental defilements. Furthermore, the scriptures contain warnings about the potential dangers and misuses of the mundane powers ², underscoring that these abilities, however spectacular, are not the ultimate aim. This implies that if the mundane Abhinnas are developed, their ideal role is to support or confirm the path to liberation, rather than becoming ends in themselves. Their “mundane” classification signifies that they still operate within the realm of conditioned phenomena and, on their own, do not guarantee freedom from the cycle of suffering.

The following table summarizes the six Abhinnas as detailed in the Pali Canon and the Visuddhimagga:

Table 1: The Six Abhinnas in the Pali Canon and Visuddhimagga

Pali Name	English Translation	Core Description (Canonical/Visuddhimagga)	Attainment Basis	Mundane/ Supramundane	Key Sutta/Visuddhimagga References
Iddhi-vidha	Various Psychic Powers	Manifesting multiple forms, invisibility, passing through objects, walking on water, flying, touching sun/moon, mastery over body.	Fourth Jhana, specific kasiṇas (e.g., space, water kasiṇa for specific powers).	Mundane (lokiya)	DN 2, DN 34, M 4, M 6; Visuddhimagga Ch. XII 5
Dibba-sota	Divine Ear (Clairaudience)	Hearing human and divine sounds, far and near, beyond normal range.	Fourth Jhana.	Mundane (lokiya)	DN 2, DN 34, M 4, M 6; Visuddhimagga Ch. XIII 3
Ceto-pariya-ñāṇa	Penetration of Others’ Minds (Telepathy)	Knowing the thoughts, emotions, and intentions of other beings.	Fourth Jhana.	Mundane (lokiya)	DN 2, DN 34, M 4, M 6; Visuddhimagga Ch. XIII 3
Pubbe-nivāsānussati-ñāṇa	Remembrance of Former Existences (Retrocognition)	Recalling one’s own past lives with details of names, experiences, births, and deaths.	Fourth Jhana.	Mundane (lokiya)	DN 2, DN 34, M 4, M 6; Visuddhimagga Ch. XIII 3
Dibba-cakkhu (Cutūpapāta-ñāṇa)	Divine Eye (Clairvoyance)	Seeing beings pass away and be reborn according to their kamma; understanding their karmic destinies.	Fourth Jhana.	Mundane (lokiya)	DN 2, DN 34, M 4, M 6; Visuddhimagga Ch. XIII 3
Āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa	Knowledge of the Extinction of Cankers	Direct knowledge of the complete eradication of mental defilements (sensual craving, becoming, ignorance); realization of Arahantship and Nibbāna.	Penetrating Insight (vipassanā) based on profound samādhi.	Supramundane (lokuttara)	DN 2, DN 34, M 4, M 6; Visuddhimagga 5

II. The Path to Abhinna: The Role of Jhana and Meditative Development

The attainment of the Abhinnas, particularly the five mundane powers, is not depicted in the early texts as a haphazard occurrence but as the fruit of rigorous and systematic meditative training. Central to this training is the cultivation of profound mental concentration (samādhi), which reaches its zenith in the states known as jhāna.

A. Samādhi as the Foundation: The Indispensability of Deep Concentration

The Pali Canon and the Visuddhimagga consistently emphasize that deep concentration, or samādhi, is an indispensable prerequisite for the emergence of the Abhinnas.⁵ The five mundane powers, specifically, are described as being attainable “through the utmost perfection in mental concentration”.⁵ This profound level of mental cultivation is essential for the mind to gain the stability, purity, and potency required to access these extraordinary abilities.

The concept of samādhi is a cornerstone of Buddhist meditative practice. It is the eighth factor of the Noble Eightfold Path, termed Right Concentration (sammā-samādhi), and is frequently defined in the suttas by the attainment of the four jhānas.¹³ The Visuddhimagga, in its comprehensive threefold structure of Buddhist training—Sīla (ethical conduct), Samādhi (concentration), and Paññā (wisdom)—dedicates a substantial portion to the detailed exposition of samādhi practices before addressing wisdom or the supernormal powers.⁴

The repeated textual emphasis on “utmost perfection” in concentration suggests that the Abhinnas are not casual byproducts of light or superficial meditative states. Rather, they demand a profound and sustained development of mental discipline. The jhānas themselves represent a progressive series of states, each characterized by a deeper level of concentration and mental refinement than the last.¹⁵ This implies a rigorous training regimen wherein the mind becomes exceptionally stable, purified, and potent—qualities that are fundamental for the manifestation of these supernormal knowledges. This counters any notion that such powers might arise accidentally or with minimal meditative effort, highlighting the demanding nature of their cultivation.

B. The Fourth Jhana: The Crucial Launching Point for Mundane Abhinnas as per the Visuddhimagga

While deep samādhi in general is foundational, the Visuddhimagga, along with key canonical texts like the Samaññaphala Sutta (DN 2), consistently identifies the Fourth Jhāna as the specific and crucial launching point for the development of the five mundane Abhinnas.²

The unique characteristics of the Fourth Jhāna render it particularly suitable for this purpose. It is marked by profound equanimity (upekkhā) and a high degree of purity of mindfulness (sati-parisuddhi). Unlike the preceding jhānas, it is free from the factors of pleasure (sukha) and pain (dukkha), as well as the more active joyful states of rapture (pīti).¹⁷ This results in a mental state that is exceptionally stable, pliant, malleable, and workable. The Samaññaphala Sutta describes the mind emerging from the Fourth Jhāna as “concentrated, purified, and bright, unblemished, free from defects, pliant, malleable, steady, and attained to imperturbability”.⁷ It is this highly refined and potent state of mind that is then “directed” or “inclined” towards the specific Abhinna one wishes to cultivate.⁷

The Fourth Jhāna, therefore, is not merely a state of profound calm; it represents a specific quality of mental refinement that makes the mind exceptionally potent and directable for manifesting these supernormal abilities. The absence of more agitating factors like rapture and pleasure, which characterize the earlier jhānas, coupled with profound stillness and clarity, makes the mind uniquely “workable” (kammañña) for the subtle and powerful mental operations required for the Abhinnas. The mental energy that was previously engaged with these affective factors is now fully available and highly refined, rendering the mind not just passively serene but actively powerful for these higher psychic operations.

C. Methods of Attainment: Kasina Meditation and Other Practices Described in the Visuddhimagga

The Visuddhimagga, particularly in Chapter XII titled “Iddhividha-niddesa” (Exposition of the Kinds of Supernormal Power), provides detailed methodologies for the attainment of iddhi-vidha, the various psychic powers.⁸ A primary method involves kasiṇa meditation. Kasiṇas are specific objects of meditation, such as colored discs (blue, yellow, red, white), or elemental representations (earth, water, fire, air).²⁰

This practice serves as a means to develop the profound concentration required to reach the Fourth Jhāna. Once this jhānic state is mastered using a kasiṇa as the object, the kasiṇa itself can then serve as the basis for directing the mind towards specific iddhis. The general procedure outlined in the Visuddhimagga involves several steps ⁹:

1. Emerging from the Fourth Jhāna (which was attained with a kasiṇa as the object).
2. Making a specific resolution (adhiṭṭhāna) for the desired iddhi (e.g., “May I become many,” “May I pass through this wall”).
3. Re-entering the Fourth Jhāna, maintaining the kasiṇa as the meditation object and holding the resolution in mind.
4. Emerging once more from the Fourth Jhāna, at which point the intended supernormal power is said to manifest.

For example, to gain the ability to pass through walls, the meditator would utilize the space kasiṇa (ākāsa-kasiṇa) as the basis for their resolution and concentration.⁹ Similarly, for walking on water, the water kasiṇa (āpo-kasiṇa) would be employed.⁹

The Visuddhimagga’s approach to these attainments is highly systematic and technical. It details the preliminary work required, the process of arousing the nimitta (a luminous mental sign that arises in deep concentration), and the method of extending this nimitta to achieve full absorption (appanā-samādhi) in jhāna.²⁰ The text itself acknowledges the profound difficulty of these practices, stating that “only one in a hundred or a thousand can do it” ²⁰, underscoring that these are not easily acquired abilities.

This methodical approach, emphasizing specific meditative objects like kasiṇas and precise mental manipulations involving resolution and repeated entry into jhāna, portrays the attainment of Abhinnas as a highly demanding and technical process. It is not depicted as a spontaneous mystical occurrence but rather as the result of deliberate and skilled cultivation. This contrasts with some modern interpretations that might downplay the rigor and specificity of the training traditionally considered necessary for such extraordinary manifestations. The Visuddhimagga’s admission of the difficulty involved further reinforces the “supernormal” nature of these powers.

III. Abhinnas in Living Experience: Documented Personal Accounts

While ancient texts provide the foundational framework for understanding Abhinnas, the user’s query also seeks accounts of these supernormal states from individuals claiming direct experience. Such personal testimonies, whether from contemporary meditators or respected figures of the recent past, offer a different lens through which to consider these extraordinary phenomena.

A. Contemporary Claims: Examining the Experiences of Modern Meditators

In the modern era, several individuals have shared experiences that align with descriptions of Abhinnas or related advanced meditative states.

Vern from Jhana8.com is a notable contemporary voice who claims to have experienced certain Abhinnas. He reports developing the ability of “knowing people from the inside”—a form of ceto-pariya-ñāṇa (mind-penetration)—and experiences related to the “Divine Eye” (dibba-cakkhu) after approximately eight months of dedicated meditation practice, during which he also attained higher jhānas. Significantly, he states he had no prior theoretical knowledge of these specific states when they first arose.²³ His experience of “knowing people” involved perceiving their underlying motivations, even before meeting them. His “Divine Eye” experience was a specific visual phenomenon observed on a rug, which he later connected to his unborn child.²⁴ Vern expresses conviction in the reality of his own experiences but maintains skepticism about other Abhinnas described in texts, such as the ability to move through walls.²⁴ He also notes that the deep states of jhāna often induce a sense of solitude and quietude, making practitioners less inclined to speak about their experiences.²⁴ In 2019, he undertook an “Abhinna Experiment” to investigate the repeatability of these experiences.²⁴

Another figure mentioned in contemporary discussions is Delson Armstrong. While not directly claiming Abhinna, he is alleged by others to be capable of entering nirodha-samāpatti (cessation of perception and feeling) for periods as long as six days.²⁵ Nirodha-samāpatti is an extremely advanced meditative attainment, distinct from the Abhinnas but requiring mastery of all eight jhānas as a prerequisite.²⁶ Armstrong has reportedly claimed that neuroscientists in the Netherlands conducted tests on him, particularly during his attainment of the eighth jhāna, yielding exciting results, with a scientific publication said to be pending.²⁵ This points to modern attempts to scientifically validate profound meditative states.

Daniel Ingram, author of “Mastering the Core Teachings of the Buddha” (MCTB), is often referenced in discussions of advanced meditative phenomena.²⁷ His work details various stages of insight and concentration, including nirodha-samāpatti, which he describes as a “giant power-failure of the sensate world and the mind with a powerful afterglow after the mind powers up again”.²⁷ This detailed experiential account distinguishes it from other states. While his writings focus more broadly on the path of insight and its stages, they contribute to the contemporary discourse on extraordinary meditative experiences.

These contemporary accounts often share common themes: the experiences tend to emerge unexpectedly during periods of intensive meditation, sometimes without the practitioner having prior theoretical familiarity with such states. They are typically described as profoundly impactful. However, these personal convictions are often met with a spectrum of reactions from others, ranging from keen interest to deep skepticism. Vern’s spontaneous emergence of “knowing people” and the “divine eye” ²³ exemplifies this. Similarly, the discussions surrounding Delson Armstrong’s alleged attainments reveal both fascination with extraordinary claims and an inherent skepticism, with some finding them “hard to believe” or incongruent with their existing worldview.²⁵ Vern’s decision to conduct an “experiment” to test the repeatability of his Abhinna experiences ²⁴ further highlights the desire to bridge profound subjective experiences with a more objective or verifiable understanding. This reflects a persistent tension between deeply personal experiences that defy conventional explanation and the inherent challenges in communicating or validating these experiences within a broader, often skeptical, context.

B. Twentieth-Century Masters: The Reported Siddhis of Figures like Dipa Ma

Accounts from the 20th century also feature respected Buddhist teachers who were reportedly endowed with supernormal abilities, or siddhis (a term often used interchangeably with mundane Abhinnas).

Dipa Ma (1911–1989), an Indian Buddhist master, is a prominent example. Her biography by Amy Schmidt mentions her mastery of “supernatural powers” such as mind reading and time travel.²⁹ Prominent Western Buddhist teacher Jack Kornfield, who studied with Dipa Ma, also recounts that she was a “master of dozens of kinds of meditation and even of many special powers”.³⁰ Kornfield shares a personal anecdote of receiving a blessing from Dipa Ma that involved her using “special yogic powers,” which left him filled with unshakable joy and love for days.³⁰

Furthermore, a study by Harvard psychologist Jack Engler, which included Dipa Ma, reported her as possessing a “luminous, loving mind, peaceful and completely untroubled with anger, fear, greed, or conflict of any kind.” Engler also noted her remarkable ability to spontaneously weave her responses to psychological tests into an ongoing spiritual narrative that revealed the entirety of the Dhamma, an achievement the researchers had never witnessed before.³⁰ Anecdotes from her students, detailing her wisdom and perceived abilities, form a significant portion of her biography.²⁹

These accounts of 20th-century masters like Dipa Ma often interweave descriptions of profound meditative depth, wisdom, and compassion with claims or attributions of supernormal abilities. For those close to such figures, these psychic capacities were often not viewed as sensational or isolated curiosities but as natural manifestations of a highly developed and purified mind. This perception aligns with traditional Buddhist portrayals of arahants (fully enlightened beings) and advanced meditators who, having cultivated the path to a high degree, might naturally exhibit such extraordinary qualities. The powers, in this context, are seen as integrated aspects of their overall spiritual attainment, rather than the primary focus of their practice or teaching.

C. Analyzing Personal Testimonies: Commonalities, Divergences, and Interpretive Challenges

When examining personal testimonies of Abhinna-like experiences, several commonalities emerge. These experiences are almost invariably linked to periods of deep and intensive meditation, often involving jhāna attainment. Frequently, the emergence of these abilities is described as spontaneous, rather than the result of a deliberate pursuit of powers. The impact on the individual is typically profound and life-altering, often leading to a significant shift in their understanding of reality and the mind’s potential. However, articulation of these experiences can be challenging due to their ineffable nature and the lack of common referents in ordinary language.

Divergences are also apparent. The specific types of powers experienced vary among individuals; for instance, Vern from Jhana8.com reports mind-reading and divine eye experiences but expresses skepticism about powers like moving through walls.²⁴ The duration and intensity of these experiences also differ. Interpretations of these events are heavily influenced by the individual’s background, belief system, and understanding of Buddhist doctrine.

Significant interpretive challenges accompany these accounts. The inherently subjective nature of such experiences makes external verification difficult, though attempts like the alleged neuroscientific study of Delson Armstrong represent a move towards seeking objective correlates.²⁵ The Buddhist texts themselves caution against misinterpretation and the potential for ego-inflation arising from such powers.¹⁰ There is also the possibility of psychological phenomena such as heightened intuition being misinterpreted as telepathy, or cryptomnesia (forgotten memories surfacing) being mistaken for past-life recall, alongside the ever-present factor of confirmation bias. The role of faith and immersion in a particular tradition undoubtedly shapes how these experiences are perceived, understood, and integrated by the practitioner.

The personal accounts, therefore, occupy a complex space between subjective certainty for the experiencer and the ongoing quest for objective verification or at least broader communal understanding. This mirrors a tension found within the classical texts themselves: the acknowledgment of the reality of Abhinnas on one hand, and stern warnings against their misapprehension or becoming objects of attachment on the other. The discussions found in online forums ²⁵ reflect this dynamic, showcasing a community of practitioners grappling with belief, skepticism, and the desire for clearer understanding or proof. This ongoing dialogue highlights the difficulty of integrating profound personal experiences that defy ordinary explanation into conventional worldviews, while also underscoring the transformative potential attributed to deep meditative practice.

IV. Echoes of the Extraordinary: Hearsay and Storied Traditions of Abhinnas

Beyond direct personal claims, a vast body of hearsay and traditional narratives within Buddhism recounts the supernormal powers of the Buddha and his accomplished disciples. These stories, primarily found in the Pali Canon and its commentaries, including the Jataka tales, serve not only as records of miraculous events but also as didactic tools, illustrating the profound capacities of a purified and enlightened mind.

A. Miraculous Feats of the Buddha: Narratives from the Pali Canon

The Pali Canon is replete with accounts of the Buddha performing various miracles, often to inspire faith, overcome skepticism, or create an opportune moment for teaching the Dhamma. Among the most renowned is the Twin Miracle (Yamakapāṭihāriya), performed at Sāvatthī. In this extraordinary display, the Buddha is said to have emitted fire from the upper part of his body and water from the lower part simultaneously, then alternated these phenomena, and even created multiple luminous duplicates of himself that filled the air.³³ This feat is often cited as the foremost of his iddhi (psychic power) displays and is considered performable only by fully enlightened Buddhas.

Other notable miracles include:

• Hiding Yasa in Plain Sight: Soon after his enlightenment, the Buddha encountered the young noble Yasa. When Yasa’s father came searching for him, the Buddha used his powers to make Yasa invisible, even though he was present, allowing the Buddha to teach Yasa’s father first, leading to Yasa’s full awakening.³³
• Subduing the Nāga with Fire: At Uruvela, the Buddha stayed in a fire-temple inhabited by a fierce nāga (serpent deity). When the nāga attacked with fire and smoke, the Buddha engaged in a contest of psychic fire, ultimately subduing the nāga and causing it to coil harmlessly in his alms bowl.³³ This event led to the conversion of Uruvela-Kassapa and his followers.
• Numerous other accounts describe the Buddha levitating, teleporting, manipulating elements, and outpacing the murderous Angulimala through psychic means.³³

A common thread in these narratives is that the display of such powers is often followed by a Dhamma teaching, which is consistently emphasized in Buddhism as the greatest miracle of all.³³ The powers serve to capture attention and open minds, but the ultimate aim is always the transmission of the liberating truth.

B. The Powers of Arahant Disciples: Stories of Maha Moggallana, Sariputta, Anuruddha, and Others

The Buddha’s chief disciples, particularly those who had attained Arahantship, were also frequently described as possessing various Abhinnas.

Maha Moggallana was renowned as the disciple foremost in psychic powers (iddhi).³⁵ The texts recount numerous instances of his abilities:

• Ceto-pariya-ñāṇa (Mind-Penetration): He could discern the mental states of others, for example, identifying a corrupt monk within an assembly.³⁵
• Dibba-sota (Divine Ear): He could hear the voices of spirits and converse with the Buddha from great distances.³⁵
• Dibba-cakkhu (Divine Eye): He witnessed demons, beings in other realms, and the karmic outcomes of battles. He frequently shared these visions to illustrate the law of kamma.³⁵
• Iddhi-vidha (Various Psychic Powers): This included “astral travel” to celestial realms to instruct gods, and telekinesis, such as shaking a monastery building with his toe to admonish negligent monks, shaking Sakka’s celestial palace, or fetching lotus stalks from the Himalayas for an ailing Sariputta.³⁵

Sariputta, the disciple foremost in wisdom, is less frequently associated with overt displays of iddhi compared to Moggallana, but some accounts do exist. One story tells of him using his spiritual power to assist his mother from a previous life, who had been reborn as a hungry ghost, to attain a heavenly rebirth.³⁷ While his path was primarily characterized by profound insight (paññā), the development of such wisdom is itself a fruit of advanced meditative cultivation.³⁸

Anuruddha was declared by the Buddha as the disciple foremost in the Divine Eye (dibba-cakkhu).³⁹ He was able to see beings passing away and being reborn according to their kamma, and this ability was instrumental in his own path and his teachings to others. The Anguttara Nikaya (AN 8.30) recounts the Buddha psychically visiting Anuruddha when the latter was contemplating the “eight thoughts of a great person”.⁴¹ Anuruddha’s attainment of the Divine Eye is said to have occurred after listening to the Mahavitakka Sutta.³⁹

Other disciples, like Pilindavaccha, are also mentioned as using their psychic powers for beneficial purposes, such as rescuing kidnapped children.⁴²

These stories of disciples’ powers serve multiple functions within the tradition. They illustrate the transformative potential of the Dhamma, showing that such extraordinary attainments are possible through dedicated practice. They also validate the teachings by providing living examples of their efficacy. The highlighting of specific strengths in particular disciples (e.g., Moggallana’s diverse iddhi, Anuruddha’s specialized Divine Eye) suggests that while the path is one, its fruits can manifest in varied ways according to individual proclivities and development. The Pali Canon frequently attributes these specific Abhinnas to prominent disciples, not as incidental details, but often as central elements of narratives that illustrate key doctrinal points or ethical lessons. The Buddha’s own declaration of certain disciples being “foremost” in these abilities further solidifies the early tradition’s view of these powers as real and significant attainments of advanced practitioners, always contextualized by the ultimate aim of liberation.

C. Insights from Jataka Tales: Past Life Capacities of the Bodhisatta

The Jataka tales, which recount the previous lives of Gautama Buddha during his long journey as a Bodhisatta (an aspirant to Buddhahood), also contribute to the lore of supernormal abilities.⁴³ In these stories, the Bodhisatta often exhibits extraordinary virtues and, at times, remarkable powers. These narratives primarily illustrate the gradual cultivation of the perfections (pāramīs) necessary to attain Buddhahood, with psychic abilities sometimes depicted as a natural manifestation of these highly developed qualities.⁴³

While these powers are not always explicitly termed “Abhinnas” in the technical, post-jhāna sense found in later systematic texts, they depict supernormal capacities arising from profound virtue, wisdom, and meditative development accumulated over countless lifetimes. The Jatakas thus reinforce the idea that such abilities are linked to long-term spiritual cultivation and karmic maturity.

D. Anecdotal Evidence from Various Buddhist Teachers and Traditions

Beyond the canonical era, anecdotal accounts and teachings from more recent Buddhist masters continue to touch upon or allude to Abhinna-like experiences.

In the Thai Forest Tradition, masters like Ajahn Mun Bhuridatta and Ajahn Maha Boowa are revered for their meditative prowess and profound insight. While direct and explicit claims of Abhinna in the spectacular sense are often nuanced or downplayed in this tradition (which emphasizes liberation from defilements above all else), stories of their deep meditative states and penetrating wisdom are common. Ajahn Maha Boowa, in his biography of Ajahn Mun, recounts his teacher’s profound meditative attainments and ability to teach with an almost supernatural understanding.⁴⁶ Ajahn Maha Boowa himself described a powerful dream vision that occurred after he made a solemn vow related to his meditation practice, suggesting experiences beyond the ordinary.⁴⁷

Among Burmese Masters, the influential Ledi Sayadaw discussed the traditional list of five mundane psychic powers (Abhiññāna).⁴⁸ However, he also cautioned practitioners against attempting to directly contemplate the extreme swiftness of moment-to-moment mental phenomena, deeming this the domain of a Buddha’s unique wisdom and stating that such attempts would lead to confusion rather than insight.⁴⁹ Sayagyi U Ba Khin, another key figure in the modern revival of Vipassana meditation, taught a path leading to advanced stages of insight. His student, Friedgard Lottermoser, described experiencing advanced Vipassana states and noted that among U Ba Khin’s more advanced students, even in ten-day courses, a few would have definite, albeit brief, experiences of “what they described” – possibly referring to fruition attainments or deep insights that border on the supernormal.⁵⁰

Pa Auk Sayadaw of Myanmar is renowned for teaching a system of meditation that explicitly aims at mastering the jhānas as a basis for developing vipassanā, closely following the Visuddhimagga. His methodology includes kasiṇa practice and is geared towards achieving deep absorption states.⁵¹ While specific Abhinna experiences of his students are not detailed as “stories” in the provided materials, the training system itself is designed to cultivate the very foundations from which such powers are traditionally said to arise. Several Western teachers, such as Tina Rasmussen, Stephen Snyder, and Marcia Rose, have trained extensively with Pa Auk Sayadaw and teach in his lineage, often describing the profound states of concentration cultivated through this method.⁵¹

These hearsay accounts and traditional stories, while not verifiable in a scientific or empirical sense, play a crucial role in shaping the devotional, inspirational, and pedagogical landscape of Buddhism. They reinforce the belief in the extraordinary capacities that can be awakened through dedicated spiritual practice. Such narratives serve to inspire faith (saddhā) in the teachings and illustrate the profound mental and spiritual transformations that the Buddhist path can facilitate. They provide archetypes of spiritual achievement, making abstract concepts like enlightenment and deep meditative states more tangible and relatable through the reported actions and abilities of revered figures. Even if some interpret these accounts metaphorically, their literal acceptance by many followers underpins a worldview where such powers are considered plausible outcomes of advanced spiritual cultivation.

V. Navigating the Powers: Purpose, Benefits, and Admonitions

The existence and attainability of Abhinnas, particularly the mundane psychic powers, raise important questions about their purpose, potential benefits, and the cautions advised in Buddhist teachings. The texts present a nuanced perspective, acknowledging these abilities while consistently redirecting the practitioner’s focus towards the ultimate goal of liberation.

A. The Utility of Abhinnas in the Buddhist Soteriological Framework

Within the Buddhist path to liberation (soteriology), the Abhinnas have varying degrees of utility. The sixth and most crucial Abhinna, āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa (the knowledge of the extinction of cankers), is not merely useful—it is liberation itself, the culmination of the entire spiritual journey.²

The five mundane Abhinnas, however, occupy a more ambiguous position. On one hand, they can, in certain contexts, be employed for beneficial purposes. For instance, the Buddha and accomplished disciples like Maha Moggallana are depicted using their powers to aid in teaching, guide others, or offer protection.³³ A display of iddhi might capture the attention of those otherwise unreceptive to the Dhamma, creating an opening for instruction.³³ For the practitioner, the emergence of such powers could serve as a confirmation of their meditative progress, although this is a delicate area due to the inherent risk of attachment and ego-inflation.

Furthermore, specific mundane Abhinnas like pubbe-nivāsānussati-ñāṇa (recollection of past lives) and dibba-cakkhu (the divine eye, which sees the workings of kamma and rebirth) can theoretically deepen a practitioner’s understanding of core Buddhist doctrines. Witnessing the direct continuity of life and the consequences of actions would powerfully reinforce conviction (saddhā) in teachings about rebirth, moral causality, and the urgency of striving for liberation.⁷ The Buddha himself utilized his knowledge of past lives and the karmic trajectories of beings to tailor his teachings effectively. Moggallana’s powers were often employed to guide, correct, or protect others.³⁵ Thus, when contextualized correctly and wielded with wisdom and compassion, these mundane Abhinnas could theoretically support the path by enhancing conviction, providing unique insights into the Dhamma, or enabling skillful compassionate action. However, this utility is always framed by the overarching importance of āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa; without this ultimate liberating knowledge, the mundane powers remain just that—mundane, and insufficient for true freedom.

B. Canonical Warnings: The Dangers of Attachment, Ego-Inflation, and Distraction from Liberation

Despite acknowledging the possibility of attaining mundane Abhinnas, the Pali Canon issues strong and repeated warnings against their pursuit, indulgence, or ostentatious display. The Buddha himself cautioned that fascination with psychic powers can become a significant distraction from the true goal of enlightenment.²

The Kevaddha Sutta (DN 11) is particularly illustrative of this point. In it, the Buddha expresses his dislike, rejection, and disdain for the “miracle of psychic power” (iddhi-pāṭihāriya) and the “miracle of telepathy” (ādesanā-pāṭihāriya). He argues that an unbeliever could easily dismiss such displays as mere tricks or charms, such as the “Gandhāra charm” for psychic feats or the “Maṇika charm” for mind-reading.¹¹ Instead, the Buddha champions the “miracle of instruction” (anusāsanī-pāṭihāriya)—the teaching of the Dhamma that leads to true understanding and liberation—as the only reliable and truly beneficial miracle.

The Vinaya (monastic disciplinary code) also contains rules against monks unnecessarily displaying their psychic powers, particularly for worldly gain or to impress laity. One account likens such a display for trivial reasons to a “loose woman who exhibits her undergarment for the sake of a few miserable coins,” highlighting the perceived vulgarity and inappropriateness of misusing such attainments.⁴²

The fundamental danger lies in the human tendency towards attachment (upādāna) and ego-inflation. The acquisition of extraordinary powers can easily lead to pride, a sense of specialness, and a desire for recognition or control, all of which are antithetical to the Buddhist path of humility, non-self, and relinquishment. Fascination with these powers can divert energy and attention from the more subtle and arduous work of insight meditation (vipassanā) which is essential for uprooting the defilements. Vern from jhana8.com acknowledges the traditional warning that “fascination with or pursuit of mundane powers can be a significant hindrance,” although he personally questions the absoluteness of this caution, suggesting that liberation might occur regardless.¹⁰

These canonical warnings are not necessarily a denial of the powers’ existence. Rather, they represent a pragmatic understanding of human psychology: the propensity to become attached to pleasurable or empowering experiences, to develop pride around achievements, and to mistake intermediate accomplishments (means) for the ultimate goal (ends). The Kevaddha Sutta, for instance, does not deny that psychic powers can be manifested, but it astutely points out their unreliability as a basis for establishing faith in unbelievers and their susceptibility to misinterpretation.¹² The Vinaya rules address the ethical implications and the potential for such displays to corrupt the Sangha’s integrity or its primary mission of spiritual guidance.⁴² The core Buddhist teaching on non-attachment applies to all conditioned phenomena, including extraordinary meditative states or abilities. Therefore, the admonitions are consistent with the overarching psychological and ethical framework of Buddhism, which consistently emphasizes detachment and unwavering focus on the unconditioned state of Nibbāna.

C. Āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa: The Abhinna of True Liberation

The sixth Abhinna, āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa—the knowledge of the destruction of the cankers—stands apart from the other five in its nature and significance. It is the direct and experiential realization that leads to Arahantship, the state of a fully liberated being who has overcome all suffering and the cycle of rebirth.⁵ This knowledge involves the complete eradication of the fundamental mental defilements or “cankers” (āsavas): the canker of sensual craving (kāmāsava), the canker of craving for existence (bhavāsava), and the canker of ignorance (avijjāsava).

This Abhinna is synonymous with the perfect understanding of the Four Noble Truths: the truth of suffering (dukkha), its origin (samudaya), its cessation (nirodha), and the path leading to its cessation (magga). It is the culmination of the Noble Eightfold Path and represents the direct perception of Nibbāna. Unlike the mundane Abhinnas, which can theoretically be developed by individuals outside the Buddhist tradition through concentration practices (as suggested by parallels with Hindu siddhis ⁶), āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa is presented as an attainment exclusive to those who have followed the Buddha’s path to its completion.

The unique status of āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa re-centers the entire discussion of Abhinnas firmly within the primary soteriological objective of Buddhism. Its placement as the sixth and final Abhinna in the standard enumeration gives it a position of ultimate importance.⁵ Its very definition involves the destruction of the āsavas, which is the hallmark of Arahantship and the attainment of Nibbāna. This reframes the entire set of Abhinnas: while the first five are potential, and often spectacular, byproducts of a highly developed and purified mind, only the sixth constitutes the essential, irreversible, and liberating knowledge that defines the end of the spiritual quest in the Theravada tradition.

VI. Conclusion: Synthesizing Ancient Wisdom and Experiential Claims

The Abhinnas, or supernormal knowledges, represent a fascinating and complex dimension of Buddhist meditative theory and practice. As explored through the lens of the Pali Canon, the Visuddhimagga, personal testimonies, and traditional narratives, they emerge as extraordinary capacities of mind said to be attainable through profound meditative development, particularly the mastery of the Fourth Jhāna.

A. Summary of Findings on the Nature and Attainment of Abhinnas

The term abhiññā signifies “higher knowledge” and encompasses a set of six specific powers: iddhi-vidha (various psychic powers), dibba-sota (divine ear), ceto-pariya-ñāṇa (mind-penetration), pubbe-nivāsānussati-ñāṇa (recollection of past lives), dibba-cakkhu (divine eye), and āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa (knowledge of the extinction of cankers). The first five are considered mundane (lokiya), achievable through extreme proficiency in concentration (samādhi), with the Fourth Jhāna serving as the crucial launching point, often utilizing kasiṇa meditation as a method. The Visuddhimagga provides highly detailed, technical instructions for their cultivation. The sixth Abhinna, āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa, is supramundane (lokuttara), representing the direct realization of Nibbāna and Arahantship, attained through penetrating insight (vipassanā). This distinction underscores a soteriological hierarchy: while psychic powers are acknowledged, true liberation lies in the eradication of defilements.

Personal accounts from contemporary meditators like Vern from Jhana8.com and historical figures like Dipa Ma suggest that experiences aligning with descriptions of mundane Abhinnas continue to be reported, often emerging spontaneously during intensive practice. These testimonies, while subject to interpretive challenges and lacking widespread empirical verification, provide compelling narratives of the mind’s potential. Traditional stories of the Buddha and his Arahant disciples further enrich this picture, depicting these powers as manifestations of advanced spiritual attainment.

B. Reflections on Understanding “Supernatural” States within a Buddhist Worldview

The Buddhist worldview, as presented in its classical texts, readily accommodates phenomena that extend beyond ordinary sensory experience and conventional understanding. These “supernatural” states are not attributed to external divine intervention but are seen as latent capacities within consciousness that can be awakened and developed through rigorous mental training, specifically through the cultivation of samādhi and paññā.

Reconciling these traditional accounts with modern materialist or skeptical perspectives presents an ongoing challenge. While some contemporary practitioners seek scientific validation for deep meditative states, the subjective nature of Abhinna experiences makes them difficult to study under controlled conditions. However, the primary concern within the Buddhist framework itself is not empirical proof for external observers, but the internal transformation of the practitioner. The significance of Abhinnas is always evaluated within the context of the path to liberation. They are not ends in themselves; their value is determined by whether they contribute to, or detract from, the ultimate goal of ending suffering.

C. The Enduring Fascination and Relevance of Abhinnas for Spiritual Aspirants

The Abhinnas continue to capture the interest and imagination of spiritual aspirants. This enduring fascination may stem from a deep-seated human aspiration for transcendence and a recognition of the mind’s largely untapped potential. Stories of supernormal powers can serve as powerful metaphors for the capacity of consciousness to overcome perceived limitations, inspiring practitioners to deepen their meditative efforts.

However, the consistent textual redirection towards āsavakkhaya-ñāṇa, and the warnings against attachment to mundane powers, serve as crucial grounding. The “miracle of instruction”—the clear and compassionate teaching of the Dhamma that guides beings out of suffering—remains the core emphasis. Ultimately, whether or not a practitioner develops or encounters mundane psychic powers, the path to the knowledge of the extinction of all cankers is presented as the most profound and relevant “supernormal” achievement, offering the true and lasting peace of Nibbāna. The exploration of Abhinnas, therefore, while intriguing, consistently leads back to the fundamental Buddhist pursuit of wisdom, purification, and liberation.

Vern Lovic’s Abhinna Articles

• What Is Abhinna Really Like? (Abijna, Abhinnanana)
• Abhinna – Knowing Hearts and Minds
• Abhinna Experiences – Supernatural Realms Are Real
• Recalling Past Lives – Is It Possible? (Abhinna, Abijna, Abhinnanana)
• Abhinna Types Article Translation and Notes
• My Divine Eye Experiences – Abhinna
• The Abhinna (Abhijna) Experiment
• Abhinna Experiences – Direct Accounts
• Abhinnas vs. Siddhis – A Deep Comparison
• Meditation, Jhana, Abhinna Experience Overview
• Divine Eye Abhinna Experiences | Anybody Have?
• Abhinna – Video Clips in the Mind
• Divine Eye Abhinna Experiences | Anybody Have?

Works cited

1. Definitions for: abhiññā – SuttaCentral, accessed May 7, 2025, https://suttacentral.net/define/abhi%C3%B1%C3%B1%C4%81
2. Abhijñā – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abhij%C3%B1%C4%81
3. Other Direct-knowledges (abhiññā-niddesa) [Chapter XIII], accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/visuddhimagga-the-pah-of-purification/d/doc1085097.html
4. Visuddhimagga – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visuddhimagga
5. abhiññā – Palikanon, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.palikanon.com/english/wtb/a/abhinna.htm
6. What Is Abhinna Really Like? (Abijna, Abhinnanana) – Jhana8, accessed May 7, 2025, https://jhana8.com/what-is-abhinna/
7. Samaññaphala Sutta: The Fruits of the Contemplative Life, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/dn/dn.02.0.than.html
8. The Supernormal Powers (iddhividha-niddesa) [Chapter XII], accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/visuddhimagga-the-pah-of-purification/d/doc1085094.html
9. Full text of “Visuddhimagga” – Internet Archive, accessed May 7, 2025, https://archive.org/stream/Visuddhimagga/Visuddhimagga_djvu.txt
10. Are the Abhinnas (Supernatural Powers) Real? – Jhana8, accessed May 7, 2025, https://jhana8.com/are-the-abhinnas-supernatural-powers-real/
11. Kevatta (Kevaddha) Sutta – Access to Insight, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/dn/dn.11.0.than.html
12. DN 11 – Kevaddha Sutta – Leigh Brasington, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.leighb.com/dn11.htm
13. Samadhi – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samadhi
14. Ajahn Chandako – Samatha and Vipassana in Harmony (A Honed …, accessed May 5, 2025, https://www.dhammatalks.net/Books3/Ajahn_Chandako_Samatha_and_Vipassana_in_Harmony.htm
15. Right Concentration – GipsyTeam, accessed May 4, 2025, https://forum.gipsyteam.ru/index.php?act=attach&type=post&id=734910
16. Dhyana in Buddhism – Wikipedia, accessed May 4, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhyana_in_Buddhism
17. Buddhist meditation – Wikipedia, accessed May 4, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhist_meditation
18. Fourth jhana: Significance and symbolism, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.wisdomlib.org/concept/fourth-jhana
19. The Eight Jhanas (Jhanas 1-4 and 4 Arupa Jhanas), accessed May 7, 2025, https://jhana8.com/the-eight-jhanas/
20. Visuddhimagga Jhānas, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.leighb.com/rc/more/Visuddhimagga_Jhanas.htm
21. The Buddha and His Teaching – Narada – 36, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.budsas.org/ebud/budtch/budteach36.htm
22. Kasina meditation – Eesti Theravaada Sangha, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.sangha.ee/meditation-and-development-center/kasina-meditation
23. Abhinna Experiences – Direct Accounts – Jhana8, accessed May 7, 2025, https://jhana8.com/what-is-abhinna/abhinna-experiences-my-background/
24. Abhinna Experiences – Supernatural Realms Are Real | Jhana8, accessed May 7, 2025, https://jhana8.com/abhinna-experiences-supernatural-realms/
25. [Metta] Delson Armstrong: entering suspended animation (nirodha-samapatti for 6 days) : r/streamentry – Reddit, accessed May 5, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/streamentry/comments/qoas5p/metta_delson_armstrong_entering_suspended/
26. Nirodha Samapatti in Theravada Buddhism – drarisworld, accessed May 4, 2025, https://drarisworld.wordpress.com/2020/07/15/nirodha-samapatti-in-theravada-buddhism/
27. Nirodha Sampatti VS Phala Samapatti. Is there a difference? – Discussion – www.dharmaoverground.org, accessed May 4, 2025, https://www.dharmaoverground.org/discussion/-/message_boards/message/348276
28. A list of every book (and movie) mentioned in MCTB2 – Discussion – Dharmaoverground.org, accessed May 4, 2025, https://www.dharmaoverground.org/discussion/-/message_boards/message/21878934
29. Dipa Ma: The Life and Legacy of a Buddhist Master: Schmidt, Amy …, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.amazon.com/Dipa-Ma-Legacy-Buddhist-Master/dp/0974240559
30. My Teacher Dipa Ma: The Remarkable Possibilities of the …, accessed May 7, 2025, https://jackkornfield.com/my-teacher-dipa-ma-the-remarkable-possibilities-of-the-awakened-heart/
31. How are prolonged cessations useful to spiritual development? : r/Buddhism – Reddit, accessed May 5, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/Buddhism/comments/1303p4s/how_are_prolonged_cessations_useful_to_spiritual/
32. Jhanas at stages 9-10 : r/TheMindIlluminated – Reddit, accessed May 4, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/9k49z7/jhanas_at_stages_910/
33. Miracles of Gautama Buddha – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_of_Gautama_Buddha
34. The Twin Miracle – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Twin_Miracle
35. Maha-Moggallana – Access to Insight, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/hecker/wheel263.html
36. Maudgalyayana – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maudgalyayana
37. Sariputta, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.toaikhanh.com/read.php?doc=0042&lan=en
38. Śāriputra – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C5%9A%C4%81riputra
39. Venerable Anuruddha: Significance and symbolism, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.wisdomlib.org/concept/venerable-anuruddha
40. Arahant Anuruddha: Foremost in the Divine Eye – drarisworld – WordPress.com, accessed May 7, 2025, https://drarisworld.wordpress.com/2021/02/03/arahant-anuruddha-foremost-in-the-divine-eye/
41. Anuruddha Sutta – Access to Insight, accessed May 7, 2025, https://accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/an/an08/an08.030.than.html
42. Buddhist Studies: The Buddha and His Disciples – The Two Chief Disciples – buddhanet.net, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.buddhanet.net/e-learning/buddhism/disciples08/
43. Jataka tales – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jataka_tales
44. Jātaka (Pali Canon) – Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J%C4%81taka_(Pali_Canon)
45. Jatakas: the many lives of Buddha as Bodhisattva (article) | Khan Academy, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/art-asia/south-asia/x97ec695a:1000-b-c-e-500ce-indo-gangetic-plain/a/jatakas-the-many-lives-of-buddha-as-bodhisattva
46. Buddhist Masters and their Organisation – Phra Ajahn Maha Boowa Nanasampanno – buddhanet.net, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.buddhanet.net/masters/mahaboowa/
47. Ajaan Maha Boowa – Forest Dhamma, accessed May 7, 2025, https://forestdhamma.org/about/ajaan-maha-boowa/
48. Five Questions on Kamma / q&aledi.htm – MyanmarNet.net, accessed May 7, 2025, http://www.myanmarnet.net/nibbana/q&aledi.htm
49. Ledi Sayadaw’s note on momentariness – Abhidhamma – Classical Theravada, accessed May 7, 2025, https://classicaltheravada.org/t/ledi-sayadaw-s-note-on-momentariness/697
50. A First Encounter with Sayagyi U Ba Khin – Insight Myanmar, accessed May 7, 2025, https://insightmyanmar.org/insight-myanmar-blog/2025/2/15/a-first-encounter-with-sayagyi-u-ba-khin
51. Perspectives on Sutta and Visuddhimagga Jhanas, accessed May 7, 2025, https://jhana8.com/perspectives-on-sutta-and-visuddhimagga-jhanas/
52. Pa-Auk Tawya, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.paaukforestmonastery.org/